Significant Discoveries From Studying Other Religions #2

As a “freebie” question at the end of a test on Hinduism and Buddhism I gave the following question: “Explain the most significant piece of religious information that you’ve learned so far from this class and how it has impacted you.”  Here is one high school student’s answer but to understand his answer you might need to be familiar with Buddhism’s 4 Noble Truths and the 3 Marks of Reality:

The most significant piece of religious information that I’ve learned so far from this semester is about the 4 Noble Truths and 3 Marks of Reality in Buddhism.  I disagree with the 3 Marks of Reality because God doesn’t change, he has a permanent identity, and has released us from suffering by dying on the cross.  Also, I agree that desire will end in suffering, but to live is not to suffer.  God gave us lives as a gift, not for us to plainly suffer.  We are free from suffering when we faith in Jesus, not when we follow the 8-fold Path.  This impacted me because I don’t have to follow a certain rule in order to be saved.  Also, I was grateful that I don’t have to view living as equal to suffering.

 

 

Signifianct Discoveries From Studying Other Religions #1

After studying Hinduism and Buddhism a high school student wrote the following response to a “gimme” essay question: Explain the most significant piece of religious information that you’ve learned so far this semester from this class and how it has impacted you.  Here is one reply I received:

The most significant piece of religious information I’ve learned thus far is Hinduism’s lack of exclusivity.  It is truly a religion based on whatever works for the individual.  This though struck me in particular when we were watching the HowCast on Youtube on how to conduct your own Hindu rituals.  The number of options presented in how to complete even just one ritual were overwhelming.  There are no lines drawn anywhere and really no specific guidelines for worship.  It is their belief that all paths will eventually lead to Brahman that is disconcerting given all the contradictions put forth by nearly every other religion.

Here is the video the student references in his answer: