Why Does God Allow Evil?

The problem of evil is presented as follows:

An omnibenevolent God would want to eliminate evil.

An omnipotent God would be able to eliminate evil.

Yet evil still exists.

  1. God is willing to eliminate evil but not able. Therefore he is impotent.
  2. God is able but not willing. Therefore God is malevolent (lacking goodness).
  3. An omnibenevolent and omnipotent God must not exist.

Kenneth Samples in his book, Without a Doubt, provides 3 answers for how to respond to this objection to the existence of an all-powerful and all-good God:

1.  Free-will
2.  God would allow evil for a time if it would produce a greater good.
3.  For God to eliminate evil in a way that would produce a greater good, it might not be instantaneous or painless, even for Him.

The following video shares these arguments in much more detail:

After posting this video to Facebook, I received the following two comments:

1.  “Without faith it is impossible to please God. . .” Theology is wonderful, but too often many are left-out, because it is complex, controvertible, and can be confusing. The BEST answer is we can trust that God is good, because Jesus died on the Cross for us, took our sins and shared our sufferings: (1 Corinthians 2:2), was testified to by the prophets and fulfilled the prophecies: ( e.g. Psalms 22, Isaiah 53) .” – Dennis Tsiorbas

2.  “There’s a recently released book from CPH called “Making the Case for Christianity: Responding to Modern Objections,” where Dr. Angus Menuge’s chapter gives a wonderful response about how typical answers to that question (God has a plan, it’s for a greater good, good still outweighs evil, etc.) are all ultimately unsatisfactory, and the best answer to the question of what God is doing about evil is the cross of Jesus Christ. Highly recommend the entire book (save, perhaps, one chapter) to anyone interested in philosophy or dealing with typical “new atheist” objections.” – Joe Hanson

I agree with them and here is my reply:

I think explaining free-will and what life would be like if that were completely stripped away and explaining how God will allow evil for a time if it will produce a greater good are necessary to show how evil and the existence of an all-powerful and all-good God are not incompatible, but then closing with Christ as the ultimate example of this demonstration of God allowing evil to produce good is superb. Depending on the situation, I think this is a good baby-steps answer up to the cross of Christ. Just going straight to the cross of Christ is typically good, but for this objection I really do like to baby-step it, because through the process of the arguments it will dawn on the person for God to completely eradicate evil, God would have to remove all of us from this world, once that seeps in, and the person recognizes their sinfulness, the best answer of the cross is truly good news.

I like to ask people, “What’s the most evil act that has ever occurred in human history?” I offer that God dying in the person of Jesus by the hands of his own creation is the greatest act of evil ever to have occurred in history, and that from the worst evil, came the greatest good – salvation for mankind.

Published by

Andy Wrasman

I live in Lilburn, GA, with my wife and two young kids. I am a pastor at Oak Road Lutheran Church. I've written a book called, Contradict - They Can't All Be True. Be sure to visit my other website: https://www.contradictmovement.org.

5 thoughts on “Why Does God Allow Evil?

  1. You need to look at all the aspects of God. You have above, all powerful and all good. But you do not have all knowing and you aren’t necessarily including Love.
    Try to personalize it. Before you accepted Jesus, did you commit a sin? (i.e. do evil.) If God removed all evil, and you have free-will you have then willfully done evil and you would need to be eilminated. God knows you wilfully did evil (all knowing), he can eliminate you (all powerful), Removing evil is good (all good) but God loves you anyway (Jesus on the cross.)

    Just looking at 2 attributes of God, All-Powerful and I’ll say Unevil (Goodness without love) alone we would not have the God that we do.

  2. We should also include his justness with his love. Those two aspects of his nature go hand in hand in understanding the cross. Rob Bell for instance by only focusing on God’s love ends up with universalism in his book, Love Wins. Although, I haven’t read the book, it appears from his book trailers and interviews that he does lean towards universalism, if he doesn’t actually embrace it, because for him if God is all-powerful and he loves everyone and desires that none should perish – all will be saved, eventually…. even after being in hell.

    Here’s a question I have for your unevil definition – can God be unevil, and not be love? Does omnibenvelent already incorporate the absolute best of love, justice, and righteousness? I was working under the assumption that perfect love was an aspect of perfect goodness.

  3. So what you’re saying is since we have free-will God has to allow evil? So since we are sinful we cause evil and God can’t stop it? Wouldn’t that make him still impotent and unsovereign? I don’t think that is a valid argument for why God allows evil because it shows him as not being totally sovereign.

    1. No, I never said that God can’t stop it. He will stop it, and he will do it in time, once the Gospel has gone out to all nations (Matthew 24).

      If he did stop it completely, so as to evil never ever happened in human history, then humanity would never have had free-will.

  4. We are sinful creations and brought forth in iniquity (Psalms 51:5). We are deserving of God’s wrath (Romans 6:23), but God offers grace to let us even have a breath of life since we are deserving of death and the result of his grace is that evil still exist since we are innately sinful and God is patent with us trying to lead us to repentance. And in that light God uses these evils for good in his plan.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s